Welcome, Guest
Username: Password: Remember me
12 Sep 2019
No bulk downloads - PLEASE!
SVP - Pas de téléchargement en masse


ECMWF 6 months 1 week ago #531

Temp, wind speed and humidity can be found on most grib files available included all the download possibilities provided by XyGrib.
Solar radiation is not commonly used and not even published by most models. It is usually part of non-hydrostatic models (local area models) that simulate local heat exchanges. I suggest trying the documentation for DWD-ICON, DWD-COSMO, Meteo France Arome and other open access models.

Second problem that you might have is to read the solar radiation as most grib viewer do not include it. For this is suggest using NOAA-Panolpy.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

ECMWF 5 hours 14 minutes ago #654

  • jgf
  • jgf's Avatar
  • Offline
  • New Member
  • New Member
  • Posts: 1
  • Thank you received: 0

Frank wrote: As a long retired professional meteorologist, a sailor and a cynic, I do have to question the real value of the ECMWF forecasts over and above GFS and ICON. I am well aware that ECMWF out-performs the rest, slightly better than the U.K. and a little more so than GFS and ICON. But, when I look at www.weathercast.co.uk/services/ensemble-forecast.html , I see very little consistent differences. Such differences as there are, are well within the natural uncertainty, noise if you like, in the weather. There are limits to predictability and that basic fact is not appreciated by the vast majority of the public, even the more meteorologically aware.

As a sailor, I see no point in using Predictwind to get ECMWF output. You are doing a great job, David.

I disagree.

while it is true that, on average, the global models all perform at nearly the same level.., for any individual weather system, there can be a large difference in the forecasts - especially several days out, and it is pretty common for one or two models to outperform the others by a margin that is meaningful to sailors.

While the ECMWF often scores the highest in verification tests.., and on average might be the best.., that doesn't mean it always outperforms other models, and for any given weather system, it always a good idea to figure out which model is performing the best and try to use that one. In the US, this is easier than it sounds, because the NOAA weather discussions typically include a discussion of how they believe the models are performing, and which models they are using for their forecasting. on those occasions where the EC is doing a better job, i would like to have it.

until a year or two ago, both predict wind, and Squid sold access to the 9km ECMWF - it could be downloaded in grib format and imported into routing programs like expedition and adrena. they no longer do this, because the EC decided that by making the gribs loadable in 3rd party programs, they were violating the license. there was some discussion about value-added - the license required that the re-seller not sell the ECMWF in it's original state, but somehow add value to it. I think both predict wind and squid were slightly modifying/scaling the windspeeds or something like that, but EC apparently decided that wasn't sufficient value added and prohibited them from making the data available to other programs.

as of now, predict wind still sells the 9km ECMWF, and gives away for free the 50km ECMWF - but you can only view it in their software.., you can not use it in adrena or expedition. I think squid has stopped selling ECMWF, except on a custom basis.

Personally, I would be happy to pay for ECMWF in a grib format that could be used in expedition. I am mostly a racing sailor.., and i appreciate that cruising sailors might not see the value

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Time to create page: 0.036 seconds

Resources on this site will always be free and open with no commercialization. However, operating costs of the servers to pre-process and deliver GRIB files to XyGrib are not trivial.

If you found the site useful, please share in the effort and help keep us up and running


Please Support

Go to top